Saturday, January 30, 2010

Back from the OOP 2010

This year’s OOP conference in Munich has been a lot of fun. I met Markus Völter, Stefan Tilkov, Floyd Marinescu, Jan Bosch, Eric Evans, Philippe Kruchten, Roman Pichler, Peter Hruschka, Kersten Auel, Rene Schönfeldt,  Klaus Rohe, Matthias Bohlen, Gernot Starke, Jutta Eckstein, Nico Josuttis, Gregor Hohpe, Robert C. Martin, Matthias Bohlen, Kevlin Henney and my good ole friend Frank Buschmann. Especially the networking part was overwhelming. So many speakers and participants you can learn from.The talks and keynotes are definitely helpful to hear about new trends, perspectives and experiences. But the personal communication is the essence of such conferences. That’s the reason why I don’t believe in online events. Sure, it’s a nice add-on but it cannot substitute the “human” factor. In the middle of the week we had a meeting of the Siemens Senior Software Architects where I enjoyed meeting some of the aforementioned celebrities but also the smart senior architects within Siemens who do excellent work day by day. They might not be that much in the limelight, but those people are  the real heroes of software engineering among all those “nameless” other heroes such as development heads, team leads, testers or developers. As Jan mentioned: there are two types of architects. Those talking about software architecture and those practicing it. Fortunately, I am a hybrid belonging to both types.

This year’s keynotes  offered excellent quality. I’ll never forget Uncle Bob’s entertaining talk on the polyglot programmer where he dived into the history of programming languages in a very entertaining way. Or two speakers from Zühlke Engineering who presented a great keynote on functional programming. Not to forget Gernot Starke with his talk on software architects and stealing in your neighbor’s garden. Unfortunately, I could not make it to his keynote but from what I heard it was one of the highlights.

Most of the topics presented in talks and tutorials covered the typical topics you’d expect. Cloud Computing and Functional Programming as well as Agility represented the hot topics. What I liked most were all these more practice-oriented talks offering some insights for practioners and also revealing some real life show cases. For instance, I enjoyed Kurt Höpli’s talk on building and controlling environmental sensors in a project in Switzerland. And I also experienced a lot of fun in Markus Völter’s talk on how to apply Model-Driven-Software-Development  within an embedded systems context. Never I will forget how Eric Evans and Hans Dockter presented Domain-Driven-Design convincing some attendees to participate as actors. And I’ll remember also Lothar Mieske who presented the real look-and-feel of all those Cloud Computing platforms. I could add much more but this should give you an impression and suffice as a pars pro toto.

Personally, I have been very busy the week. First, I gave a full-day tutorial on Software Architecture – From Requirements to Architecture. It was the tutorial with the largest numbers of attendees. This makes interaction somewhat difficult but nonetheless worked much better than expected. My talk on Hitchhiker’s Guide to Cloud Computing had about 80-100 attendees. To my pleasure the Global Technology Field Cluster Lead of my organization also attended the talk. For me, it was the biggest surprise that the talk “Introduction to Scala” had attracted so many people. I was totally electrified and I mean this literally cos’ static charge hit me whenever I pressed the page-down key. When people are interested, I will record this talk with Camtasia and publish the video clip in YouTube and other media. All in all, I got really overwhelming feedback. Thank you to all attendees for their nice evaluation sheets :-)

Next year the OOP will celebrate its 20th anniversary. Hope that many of you will join the event. It is really an extraordinary experience.

Thursday, January 21, 2010

Stakeholder-specific Communication

Communication is one of the most importants aspects of software architecture design. The architecture itself is a means of communicating design decisions to customers, product managers, project managers, testers, integrators, and developers. However, these stakeholders have different expectations regarding the software architecture. While developers need a clear guideline how to implement the architecture design, customers may be more interested how (well) the software meets their requirements. The software architecture documentation and all other means of communication such as presentations must cover these various perspectives. To address such broad spectrum of interests, architects could provide a specific document for each particular kind of stakeholder which leads to an unacceptable amount of effort and time. This is why documents should rather explain the architecture decisions - the "what", the "how" and the "why" - in a top-down approach and add a guide-to-the-reader motivating who (i.e. which stakeholder) should read what in which order. For presentations or other forms of communication it might be worthwhile to introduce a specific variant for each stakeholder. A project manager or customer is typically not that interested in all those strategic and tactical design destails, while developers need all the information they can get. Thus, communication between architects and other stakeholders should take the stakeholder-specific interests into account. This implies, that architects need to have a clear understanding of these interests before starting documenting or communicating. Otherwise, they won't get buy-in for their software architecture by these different stakeholders. Personally, I have experienced so many projects where managers couldn't follow and understand what the architects told them overwhelmed by details they did not (have to) care about. And I also have been in so many meetings where software architects introduced high-level abstractions that could not provide the details developers and testers expected.
As a prerequisite it is necessary to ensure a common understanding of terminology. Did you ever attend a meeting where different participants had a different understanding of terms? Communication will not work and succeed when one person is speaking english, while the communication's target can only understand spanish. This might be obvious for real languages, but it is often underestimated for domain-specific languages. Did you once try to read and understand (!) a treatment record of your physician? He speaks english, you speak english, but this won't help you much. As a consequence, introducing a domain-specific language is valuable and essential. It does not have to be a full-blown language in the strict formal sense, but often it makes sense to offer more than just a glossary. The core functional architecture should represent the problem domain.
As a consequence, all communication between architects and stakeholders must happen in a stakeholder-specific way. When giving a presentation on the software architecture, make sure you know the target audience and their interests. Don't assume, other types of stakeholders understand software architecture the way you do. You are the doctor and they are the patients, so-to-speak. Communication may succeed or fail. The risk of failure can only be minimized if you can take and understand the perspective of your communication partners.
Obviously, these statements also hold for other kinds of communication. Have you ever tried to explain to your spouse why you need that cool new gadget for several hundred bucks? Try that by telling her/him the technical specifications. Won't work very well, right? What we take for granted in such situations (i.e., adapting the communication to your communication partner), represents also a conditio-sine-qua-non in software engineering. So, better mind the stakeholder-specific communication in the future :-)

Saturday, January 09, 2010

Real Software Engineers

  • Real software engineers don’t need safety nets. Instead, they are ready to face all dangers and risks without any fear. For this reason, they dislike (unit) testing, because (unit) testing is for pussies (i.e., those who do not trust their own code.) Since real software engineers never make mistakes, testing would be a mere waste of time.
  • Real software engineers won’t document their design, because these designs contain an incredible amount of design pearls other mortals would not be able to comprehend, anyway.
  • Nor do real software engineers read other design documents nor manuals, either because their fellow engineers did not provide documentation or because they do not trust these documents.
  • Instead, their main guidelines are:
    • All you need is code
    • Bubbles don’t crash
  • Real software engineers do not check or prioritize requirements. Instead, they got intuition for customers’ needs which drives all their activities.
  • Real Software Engineers do not communicate (much) with other stakeholders, because other stakeholders are just obstacles on the way to project completion. That’s also the reason why real software engineers hate meetings.
  • Real software engineers do rarely speak English, German, …. They rather express themselves using C#, Java, C++, …
  • Real Software Engineers feel more comfortable in the solution domain. Their goal is to provide solutions instead of getting lost in problem domains. This is why they prefer playing around with solution technologies.
  • Real software engineers can turn any problem into a nail for which they can use their favourite hammer.
  • Real software engineers do not need software architecture because a predefined architecture would just limit their creativity. A good architecture is always created ad-hoc for solving real problems in a pragmatic way.
  • Real software engineers do not foster re-use. First of all, re-use has never worked in practice. And secondly, re-using design or code typically requires more resources than reinventing the wheel. This is often due to the fact that re-usable artifacte were created by other real software engineers who failed to document their work.
  • Real software engineers won’t read this blog because in the time needed for reading, they could add another feature to their software.

Thursday, January 07, 2010

Architecture Documentation Revisited

Did you ever read a novel which later has been used as foundation for a movie? I bet, you were rather disappointed how the movie differed from your reading experience and thus from your expectations.

Did you ever read an architecture document – yes, there is vague evidence and hope that something such as architecture documents exists – and then compared the documented design with the implemented system?

In software architecture design, documents are not just by-products created for write-only brain dumps.  Instead, they are supposed to be read by someone – a fact that might be surprising for some engineers.

Architecture documents serve as the basic means for communicating architectural decisions, i.e. they explain the “what” and the “why” – aka design rationale. Target audience of architecture documents are foremost all stakeholders, not just the authors themselves.

In addition, those documents should be up-to-date. Did you ever struggled through 100s of pages of a design document, and right after you finished, someone told you, the document was outdated?

Does this mean, we should adapt the documentation after each change? No, it only implies, architecture documents should be updated regularly. Consider versioning architecture documents in this context!

An architecture specification should also be subject for testing. Don’t take testing too literally! What I suggest is that documents are being reviewed for their usability/readability, internal consistency and completeness, as well as their consistency with the actual implementation. Needless to mention, that the reviewers shouldn’t be the authors but a selection of stakeholders.

Always use the right style of documentation depending on purpose and target audience. A user document that describes a system should contain tutorials as well as a reference manual. If no one understands it, the best design ever won’t help you much.

My strategy for documenting is to walk to the other side of the fence thinking about how a specific stakeholder would like to get the material presented. I am not writing the document for myself but for others, anyway. And I always take care of updating the documentation whenever the system has been updated to a new (minor or major) version. Readers should not be punished by reading my document but consider this as an entertaining and profitable activity. Reading design documents is fun or at least should be! Who claims, IT documents must always be written in a technical and boring style?

Remember: the most important capability of a software architect are communication skills. Documenting is one particular way of communicating.

Wednesday, December 09, 2009

A picture can say more than thousand words - a word can say more that thousand pictures

One of the key problems in architecture documents is the idea illustrations are sufficient for explaining design.

Let me give you an example:

Eo---oP

What could the diagram illustrate?

Could this describe a hydrogen atom consisting of a proton and an electron?

Does it represent the association between an entity bean and its persistence store?

Or is it something completely different?

Diagrams are models. They can only express a subset of reality. If you do not know the concrete context, you’ll have no way to figure out what the diagram actually means.  But if you are familiar with s special context, you might be inclined to map a diagram to your own context which, however, might be painfully wrong.

Thus, an architect should always explain the context of a diagram as well as the constituents and their meaning textually in the document.

What about the other way round?

Again, an example:

Component A is connected with B, C, D. D is connected with E and C. F is connected with D and A … a lot of more information …

In the example above, plain text is not really helpful. Here seems to be a good place to add a diagram that graphically illustrates the components and their connections. Text alone is not capable of describing complex structures which often appear in architecture design.

Hence, we recognize that diagrams need explanations to understand their semantics. Otherwise they just represent syntactic glibberish. In addition, UML, SysML and other graphical notations might lead to ambiguous illustrations which are open to interpretation. Thus, tell the reader what exactly the model behind the diagram is supposed to be.

As a consequence, all design documents that are automatically generated have almost no value.  For example, design rationale (such as requirements and their association with architectural decisions) is better described using textual language instead of diagrams.

Thus, use diagrams carefully in your design documents. But also be aware of text that does only describe what is depicted in diagrams, but does not introduce information such as pre- and postconditions, invariants, contextual information, design rationale, …

Guess, why there are UML use case diagrams that illustrate a set of use cases, but no graphical means for describing the use cases themself?

Use text and diagrams wisely! Don’t consider design documents as write-only-entities. You will see what I mean whenever you have to understand  documents of your fellow engineers.

Sunday, November 29, 2009

Maturity matters

This time a rather small posting only.

I am wondering what the top research fields in software architecture currently are? Of course, fields such as MDSDL/DSLs come immediately to my mind. Cool stuff! Investigate these topics and fame is guaranteed!

Others are already sufficiently mature. I am thinking of mapping requirements to architecture decisions. Ok, maybe there are still some deficiencies in this area. Hmmh, there might be even significant gaps, especially when dealing with operational and developmental qualities. Must reevaluate my opinion.

What about documenting software architecture? There are dozens of templates available, even books. A lot of agreement here, but what about modeling? Is UML the “ultimate ratio”? How can we model, what should we model? How can we cover design rationale? How deep should we go? Did I ever read a really good architecture documentation?

I got it. Patterns are super mature. I have been author of pattern books myself. These books are now available since 14 years. Some architects even know the names of all patterns. But do most architects know patterns others than GoF? And even if they do, do they apply them?

Isn’t refactoring a good candidate or reverse engineering? Architecture refactoring isn’t established in most development organizations. If I say architecture refactoring, I really mean architecture refactoring, not code refactoring.

What about software architecture design? We have been designing software systems for decades and they work! No, most of them suck! Unfortunately, design by accident is the norm, not the exception.

… thinking, diving deeper, diving broader, getting frustrated …

Why is my impression that most areas in software architecture are still rather immature?

Maybe, the answer is that software architecture itself is a big collection of research topics.

Or maybe, I am blinded by the light.

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Architect – what architect?

In many projects and organizations I am constantly meeting software architects. Given the quantity I’d only expect only a fraction of software development projects to encounter any issues in software architecture and design. As we all certainly know, quite the opposite is true.

Ok, nice and true words, but what exactly is the reason for this observation?  

Of course, I absolutely have no clue :-; So let me just make some assumptions.

Could it be that the term “software architect” on a business card is subject to a variety of different interpretations?

In one company, someone may be promoted to software architect, just because she/he is the only one who owns a pattern book. [Beware of humour!]

Consulting companies may entitle some of their engineers as software architects, because they can charge more for architects than for developers.

A handful of companies may offer a challenging education program to become a software architect.

With other words, it is not clearly defined what a software architect is or should be. Nothing prevents you from calling yourself a software architect. You may remember that I am proposing a rather tough profile for software architects. Well, I know too many projects that failed  miserably because of lack of competencies, experience or skills by the responsible software architects.

Note: not only the skills count! As software engineering is heavily related to communication and learning from failure, becoming a software architect requires starting as a developer, taking over more and more responsibilities over the years, before finally turning into a butterfly.

Another issue I often encounter is the missing separation between software and system architects. Today, many system architects are also considered as software architects. This might work very well if the system architect is an experienced software architect. Likewise, the aforementioned setting is adequate for software-intensive developments. But here again, the system architect needs also to be an experienced software architect. If the latter doesn’t hold, the software relevance is obviously underestimated and will inevitably lead to trouble.

Hold on, there is even another possibility. Even if you can justify that you are a software architect now, this doesn’t mean you’ll be a software architect forever. One of the most fundamental challenges is to know the state of the art of relevant software technologies and methods as well as appreciating and practicing coding and testing skills. Guess, you have been appointed as a software architect ten years ago, but in the meantime you were constrained to using UML tools, Powerpoint and other Office applications. With other words: would you trust a surgeon to operate on your heart who lacks ten years of practice?

I bet, you made some similar experiences in your environment. If that is the case, a comment would be highly appreciated. If not, even more! 

Friday, November 06, 2009

Sick Architecture

You may wonder why my publication rate in this blog has decreased dramatically. I am staying at home due to an infection for three weeks now which wasn’t that helpful for my blog.

To keep things running I have decided to create a new posting. Well, the title is intentionally related to my current health situation.

To be honest, I think that software architecture design reveals some interesting commonalities with sickness:

  • Both often require intense treatment by experts
  • Different experts offer different opinions and treatment plans
  • Both are typically open-ended to some extent
  • Both are not subject to planning in most situations
  • Both mostly feel very miserable
  • To reduce the risk of getting infected some kind of prevention strategy is always a good advise
  • It is better to cure the cause not the symptoms. Thus, be aware of all interdependencies and follow a holistic approach
  • Viruses are a problem in both worlds
  • Healthcare never ends – it is important in the whole lifecyle
  • Learning from failure is recommended to avoid similar problems in the future
  • Prevention is always better  (i.e, cheaper) than healing

Most software architectures I know are not in a good and healthy shape - at least in some intermediate phases. Why? Because they were not devleoped with the aforementioned bullet list in mind.  Thus, health monitoring (i.e, reviews) and treatments (i.e., refactoring) should be an essential tool in the architect’s framework.

Does this sound reasonable?

Thursday, October 15, 2009

Data centric Architecture

In most projects there is a big emphasize on functionality. Use case modelling defines responsibilities of the system as well as how it interacts with actors. Logical modelling then maps the use cases to related subsystems/components which, of course, is functionality based. At the end we'll get functional interfaces between subsystems or between components. Do you recognize that methods such as UML mostly focus on methods?



However, in many cases the data exchanged between architectural entities is rather complex. For example, in healthcare scenarios complex structures with patient information or charging information are the rule. Not dealing with data as first class citizens might lead to various issues such as versioning problems, or inadequate partitioning or aggregation of data. Thus, architects should deal with data modelling very soon if they are facing complex structures in their development projects.



Data modelling starts with the domain model. What are the main entities in your problem domain and which kind of data do they need to persist, share, or transfer?

Then in the next "layer" when we are introducing the subsystems we'll have to think about data structures in subsystems and data structures exchanged between subsystems. For example, what exactly are the data structures required in the functional interfaces. Obviously, these data structures can be partially derived from the domain model with further data structures required by infrastructural entities or non-functional qualities.

In the component layer we are starting to deal with finer grained data types.

Last but not least we'll have to define how data is mapped to implementation artifacts.



Thus, we should also follow a top-down approach for data modelling. And likewise we need to consider bottom-up constraints such as special data requirements of infrastructures or platforms. With other words, data modelling must go hand in hand with all the other architectural modelling activities:



Important questions to ask when modelling data:


  • Who is the originator of data?

  • Who is the consumer of data?

  • How does data move from the originator to the consumers?

  • Do we need to collect/aggregate data from different sources (transfer objects)?

  • What about quality constraints such as performance (e.g., caching data), security (e.g., encrypting data), modifiability (e.g., versioning data), concurrency (e.g., locking data), availability and reliability (e.g., replicating data, data persistence)?

  • Where and how is data stored?

  • How do different data structures depend/relate?

I think, data modelling is an underestimated and undervalued activity in architecture design. What about your experiences and opinions?

Friday, September 18, 2009

Ineffective Communication

It might not be that obvious why time management is of high importance especially for software architects. But of course, being a software architect in a mission critical project requires your full attention. However, in a couple of projects I met software architects who were simply overwhelmed by communication requests and finally got stuck in a kind of waste time singularity. Ineffective communication can significantly reduce your productivity. 

Unfortunately, there are many opportunities where your focus on the real important things is easily lost.

  • My favourite are unnecessary meetings (including telephone conferences).  As software architects are caught in the gravitational center of the project they receive a lot of meeting requests, by managers, developers, other engineers. If you are a very communicative and friendly person – and I bet you are – you might be inclined to say “yes, we can” to all those nice invitations. It is often overseen that meetings also require preprocessing and postprocessing activities. Hence, don’t just count the time you’re spending in the meeting room! Consider carefully what type of meeting you are asked to attend. Is it an essential meeting where your participation is absolutely required (class A meeting)? Or more one of those nice-to-have-meetings? Only accept class A meeting invitations! Even for class A meetings ask yourself whether this meeting has the right setting in terms of people invited, time frame, goals, agenda. With other words: is the benefit you obtain larger than the time spent? Sometimes, a small face-to-face meeting offers more value than a large official meeting. And of course, act thoughtfully if you invite to meetings yourself! As an Outlook junkie do not only enter meetings in your calendar but also time slots for your actual work. Mind the fact that other people tend to fill the gaps in your calendar assuming those gaps are indications of idle time. Personally, I also enter slots for my spare time, just in case. Needless to say that you should also consider travel time in this context. Care about meeting netiquette: there is no place for cell phones or notebooks in a meeting – a few exceptions granted.
  • Another critical challenge is e-mail. Communication by e-mail can be very ineffective (but also the most effective means in other situations). Try to reduce corporate spam which consists of all those mails which steal your time for no good reason. Organize your inbox in folders and prioritize mails as soon as it arrives. Process the mail depending on its priority. Read mail only at specific points of time and tell your communication peers about this fact. And do not send unnecessary mail yourself! Before writing an e-mail, always hold on and consider whether you would also have sent an letter containing the same information in the stone age of communication.

At the end, it is the project success that counts. Good results require effective architects with as much productive working time as possible. Productive hours depend on effective communication. It is the quality not the quantity!

Saturday, September 05, 2009

Vacation - the end is near

The last weeks I have relaxed a lot: visiting Dresden, running, swimming and biking, as well as practicing with my DSLR. In addition, I read two books on Scala, updated an article on D (the language), installed several apps on my IPhone (yag – yet another gadget),  prepared slides for ADC 2009 and OOP 2010, participated in a new episode for our SoftwareArchitecTOUR podcast, … and spent a little time on further expanding my work on architecture refactoring.

However, I intentionally did not work on software architecture or on this blog. This will change beginning with upcoming monday. Now, that I got some new and fresh ideas, I can continue my journey on software architecture issues.

By the way: I did not mention it so far but maybe you like to follow me on twitter (username: stal_m).

Friday, August 21, 2009

And now for something completely different

This is my first week of a 3 weeks vacation. It is really hot in Munich why I am currently enjoying swimming, biking and visiting beer gardens more than software engineering.

Nonetheless, I am currently educating myself in a new programming language. Scala by Martin Odersky combines a pure object-oriented langauge with functional features. And it runs on the JVM. An earlier version of Scala does also support the .NET CLR.

What I like most is the proper integration of functional features. Closures, for comprehensions, nested functions, pattern matching are notable examples. While Scala is statically typed (it is not a dynamic language), it offers type inference for variables, arguments and results.

In addition, it provides some cool extensions to Java: all types are objects, no static members, support of covariance and contravariance, to name a few.  Traits are available instead of interfaces – they can behave like interfaces but also allow implementations of methods. With traits the problem of multiple inheritance (mind the diamond configuration) can be avoided. This is possible by introducing inheritance linearization and a kind of virtual super.

With all of these features Scala code can be much more compact than Java - and it interoperates well with Java components.

Well, I am really kinda enthusiastic. If you ask me, Scala could be a strong competitor for Java and C#.  But of course, there is not a big company backing Scala such as Sun or Microsoft. Thus, the community will decide.

Loving the JVM but preferring other languages than Java? No more excuses, Dave!

Saturday, August 01, 2009

Neverending Story

One of the prominent questions I often hear in software development projects is when to start with architecture design. Sometimes, architects hesitate to start until almost all requirements are available in high quality. This strategy is highly recommendable when you like to postpone architecture design forever. There is not a single project with medium to high complexity I remember where we knew all forces in full depth and breadth at project start.

First of all, it heavily depends on the software development process. In a Waterfall model without iterations you are stuck anyway. Thus, I generally recommend an iterative-incremental approach. In software developments with all their volatility only piecemeal growth can succeed.

It is important to have a sufficient quality and quantity of requirements available, for example, the most important 30%-50% of use cases and non functional qualities with unique priorities. This way, you can come up with a conceptual architecture which you can then use as a base for iterative-incremental refeinement.

After the baseline is available prioritize all user requirements (use cases), map them to end-to-end scenarios and integrate them into the architecture, keeping the non-functional qualities in mind. To deal with non functional qualities let key developers, architects or even teams work on principles and guidelines how to address these qualities. Do this after the baseline architecture design but before starting the end-to-end iterations.

As soon as new requirements appear or have been concretized assign them priorities and put them into the “backlog”.

To introduce a kind of safety net for embracing change, introduce test-driven design methods, flash architecture reviews after each iteration, and (architecture and code) refactoring activities after each flash review.

Keep in mind that sometimes you need courage to decide even when not all details are available.  It is typical for all creative and volative acts that not all details are known in advance, nor the ways how to cope with them.

As a consequence, it is much more productive and effective to follow wrong paths sometimes instead of following no path at all.

To keep it simple: Prefer acting over reacting

Thursday, July 23, 2009

May the force be with you

Sometimes it is getting confusing. There are so many influential factors driving software architecture. Here is my small domain language
  • Forces is the set of all influential factors an architect is facing: requirements, risks, constraints, business needs.
  • Requirements are the (documented) set of all expectations for a software system. According to Wikipedia a requirement represents a necessary attribute, capability, characteristic, or quality of a system in order for it to have value and utility to a user.
  • System requirements address the system as a whole. From system requirements we need to derive architecturally relevant requirements that drive architecture and design. That is the architect's job.
  • A Functional requirement defines functionality a system is supposed to provide, sometimes also known as capability. Use cases are functional requirements. They define what the user expects from the system on a black-box level. User stories according to Wikipedia denote software system requirements formulated as one or two sentences in the everyday or business language of the user.
  • A Non-functional requirement (also known as quality requirement, quality attribute or "ility") is constraining a solution. There are two subcategories here: operational requirements as the name suggests constrain the runtime behavior of the system (e.g., security, performance) while developmental requirements constrain the design from a developmental perspective (e.g., maintainability, modifiability). As operational requirements often have a systemic approach to a system they are subject to architecture design and therefore are also called strategic requirements. Tactical requirements such as modifiability mostly have only local scope.
  • Constraints - what a surprise - are constraining the solution. A constraint might be technical (we need to use Windows 7 as our OS), organizational (subsystem A should be developed at location A), standard & law (we must abilde to FDA rules), business-related (target costs should not exceed xxx$).
It is the job of a software architect to base all decisions on the forces of the project. Still she/he has sufficient freedom to make architecture and design a complex task. Architecture is about communication and courage to decide.

Monday, July 20, 2009

No future for architects?

I am a big fan of Star Trek, especially of The Original Series and The Next Generation. From a technology viewpoint, it is amazing how all of these technologies such as warp drives or beaming have influenced science. Did you know that the inventor of the mobile phone had also Star Trek in mind?

However, there is one sad aspect. What about Software Engineering? Whenever software plays a role in any of the episodes, you’ll recognize Spock or Data just coding. Do they ever design? There is also no software engineering team in the Enterprise although software should be an important asset in the system architecture. I am missing a chief engineer for software engineering aspects!

Does the computer program itself? Will UML disappear in the future? Or is it just software engineering being too boring for SciFi fans? Interestingly, there are also seem to be no restrooms in the spaceships. This is what they have in common with software engineers :-)

Thus, we could ask how software engineering especially the discipline of software architects will evolve in the future? Will we still use a successor of UML in hundred years? How could the role of software architects evolve?

The best approach to predict the future is identifying space of improvement. It is very likely that such areas will be addressed. How should the ideal process of software design look like? What is the software architect supposed to know and to do?

In most SciFi movies automatization/Model-Driven Software Development and AI are often the answer. Architects express their intent, smart systems then try clarify open issues, and eventually the result is generated.

Another approach could be an organization like the Borgs who strongly follow an agile approach with code ownership, collective programming and test-first.

Any opinions?

Keep in mind: Resistance is futile!

Sunday, July 19, 2009

RRC Card

Most of you already know the CRC (depicting Class, Responsibilities, Collaborators) which is a low tech technique for discussing software artifacts in brainstorming sessions for software design.

I propose another kind of card for depicting the roles in a particular project: the RRC Card: Role Responsibilities Collaborators.

The idea is simple:

  • The first R stands for role by which I mean a concrete person and her/his role
  • The second R stands for Responsibilities: what responsibilities should this role have to meet its expectations
  • The C stands for Collaborators: from which other roles does this role depend, e.g., with which other roles must it interact

If you start with a project, you could ask the parties involved to jointly fill out these RRC cards, thus making clear how responsibilities are partitioned and how roles are supposed to interact.

Example:

---------------------------------------------------

R: Michael / Architecture Consultant

---------------------------------------------------

Responsibilities                        Collaborators

Mentor and coach                    Lead Architect: Paul

Help design                             Architect: Tom

Implement

----------------------------------------------------

 

If you already in a project in deep trouble you could ask persons to fill out how they live their own role and likewise fill out RRC cards for other persons, thus identifying conflicts between expectation and reality.

Document these RRC cards in a document (e.g., paper-based or Wiki-based)

Saturday, July 18, 2009

Risk-driven

In addition to requirements and business expectations, risks represent an important driver of architecture design activities. Not addressing risks appropriately is a major reason for project failure. But what exactly is a risk and how can I identify potential risks as an architect.

On a very coarse grained level, risk might be considered as not knowing the outcome of an event or activity. It is the threat or propability that “an action or event will adversely or beneficially affect an organisation's ability to achieve its objectives” [Wikipedia].

There are as many different types of risks in a  software development project as there are influential factors.

For example:

  • Technical risk: Is EJB the right technology for achieving 100000 transactions per hour in our Web store?
  • Organizational risk: Is the organization appropriate for this kind of development project?
  • Political risk: Does this product manager follow her/his hidden agenda? Is this supplier really trying to support us or is he in fact competing with us?
  • Design Risk: Is this design decision appropriate for dealing with the requirements?
  • Requirements risk: Do we really understand the requirements of our organization or the customers?
  • Process risk: Is this the right development process?
  • …

For dealing with risks, there are lot of different ways. Technical risks and architecture risks can be reduced by a requirements-driven, test-driven approach with explicit assessment activities and refactoring activities. Political risks require the architect to communicate and lead efficiently and effectively.

An important point is this context: to be able to deal with risks, we must make them explicit. Implicit risks are often overseen, forgotten or ignored. You should really know your “enemy”.

Making risks explicit means to document AND communicate them.

I recommend to introduce a template for risk assessment comprising:

  • Name of the risk
  • Priority/Relevance of the risk
  • Type of risk: organizational, technical, ….
  • Rationale: explain why this is a risk
  • Context: what else should we know when dealing with this risk
  • Strategies: possible ways to deal with the risk
  • Decision: the recommended strategy to deal with the risk for the concrete context, and the rationale for this decision
  • See also: other risks this risk implies or similar risks that could be treated with the same strategy

Not all of these fields need to be available in the beginning. You could start with name, type, context, thus collecting the risks first. Then, you could prioritize the risks, and eventually extend the templates for this risks identified as high risks with missing information.

Let me give you an example:

  • Name: Uncertainty Using EJB
  • Priority: high (******)
  • Type: technical
  • Rationale: capability to meet the performance requirements of 100000 transactions/hour. We are not sure whether EJB will be appropriate
  • Context: Our developers are not experienced with EJB
  • Strategies:1) Build performance prototype first. 2) Hire external expert. 3) Use Enterprise OSGi instead. 4) Outsourcing.
  • Decision: Hire external consultants. Let them build a performance prototype and then help implementing the system when EJB proves to be a reasonable choice.
  • See also: we are not sure whether MySQL can cope with the throughput requirements.

It is worth mentioning that risk assessment is not exclusively provided by software architects. In fact, all roles in the project must help and closely cooperate for risk assessment. This way, everyone involved is aware of potential risks. And of course, some risks such as those implied by organization, test quality, or quality of requirements must be identified and clarified by other roles such as product and project management, requirements engineering or test and quality management.

Architecture and design decisions should then take risks into account.

Mind the risks: The highest risk is not systematically dealing with risks. 

Friday, July 17, 2009

Who is responsible

Suppose, you are working in a software development project as a software architect. You are still waiting for the requirements to be available in sufficient quality and quantity and priorization. Even after months almost nothing happens. Sure, the problem is caused by requirements engineering. But what is your responsibility as an architect? Your responsibility is to communicate and escalate which requires courage. For example, you could tell the stakeholders what implications the current situation might have - for example, you cannot start with architecture design which means development cannot start with implementation etc. You should never fall into the "this is not my job" trap. After all, software architects need to drive the project. Sometimes, it might be even possible to take responsibility for requirements as an architect but this should be the exception not the rule.
Similar issue for test & quality: if test coverage is only limited, bugs are seldomly found during testing, or tests themselves are faulty, then you could finger point to testers and developers. However, it is your job as an architect to deal with quality. Don't try to escape your responsibility in this area. Test First Design makes it very clear that testing requires the different roles to cooperate.
What about business aspects? I know, you got this product manager who is in charge of all business aspects. But software architects are responsible in helping develop the technology roadmap, identifying patents, estimating the business implication of architecture decisions. Even more, architects must base every architectural decision on requirements and business needs.
Hmmh, what about project management? Of course, an architect should not be forced to also act as a project manager. These two rules are very difficult to live at the same time in the same project. But what if project management needs to estimate costs and resources? Here the software architect needs to provide support. What skills do developers need? How many developers and how much time are necessary to develop subsystem A.
I don't claim that architects shuld be jack of all trades but masters of none. Their main focus should be on software architecture. However, they cannot ignore what is happening on the boundaries between software architecture and the rest of the project. They should feel responsible for project success.

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Domain Models (continued)

Throughout my life as a software engineer I have participated in many different projects in various domains. Needless to say, I encountered some deja vu experiences in those projects, also known as war stories. One remarkable example always has been the problem domain itself. Even in projects with lots of experienced participants the problem domain had been often root of misunderstandings and misconceptions.  In large projects with outsourcing partners, external partners and other suppliers common knowledge of the problem domain is essential. A project  with lack of problem domain knowledge among the stakeholders is doomed to fail. Remember the tower of babel where lack of communication and insufficient common understanding lead to lethal catastrophe.

As I am mostly acting as software architecture mentor and coach or technology expert I am often master of the solution domain, but not of the problem domain. For me it is inevitable to obtain a detailed knowledge of the problem domain. This is even more important when developing product lines or platforms, because in that case lack of common understanding influences more than one product or solution.

How could we address that problem? My recommendation is to introduce a domain model. Of course, I am referring to the problem domain in this context.  A domain model is not just a glossary of terms – a common misconception I am often facing.

A domain model consists of all core concepts (actors, subsystems, components, services, …) relevant within that domain as well as the relationships and interactions between these core concepts.

 

A large domain typically consists of subdomains. For example, a telecommunications domain for Unified Communication might introduce subdomains such as basic communication or presence. As a consequence, the domain should be partitioned hierarchically into subdomains.  

There are different ways to descible a domain model, from informal approaches to strictly formal definitions such as a domain-specific language. In all cases, stakeholders might select textual or graphical representations, whatever is more appropriate.

Note that I have not assigned the responsibility of introducing a domain model to software engineers. Defining a common domain model should rather be a joint endeavor of all stakeholders, maybe driven by requirements engineers and architects.

If you have ever read definitions of software architecture like the one by ANSI/ISO, you might recognize that architecture definitions match closely with my definition of domain models. First of all, those architecture definitions are insufficient (due to their genericity). Secondly, a domain model is a good starting point for creating the architecture. Take the use cases (black box view) and specify their dynamics using the domain model entities (white box views). Supplement this architecture core with design tactics for non-functional requirements. This will lead to the architecture baseline. Using the domain model also helps you staying focused on the problem domain instead of diving to the solution concepts too early.

Eventually, a domain model defined, understood and agreed by the various stakeholders such as requirements engineers, developers, testers, architects, product managers, customers serves as a fundamental mean for architecture design and communication. 

Of course, the solution domain itself can also be expressed by a domain model. This is why the main task of an architect consists of mapping a problem domain to a solution domain.

Formalizing both to a sufficient extent helps automating this process using model-based software development approaches. Such automation, however, might be too expensive for one-off applications or smaller product lines.

Whenever you are participating in a development process in the presence or future: do not forget to specify the domain model if not already available.

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Podcast on Software Architecture

For those of you capable of understanding German, I’d like to point you to our new Podcast on Software Architecture called Software ArchitekTOUR. You may also search in the ITunes Store for the podcast and find it – for example, search for ARCHITEKTOUR in the podcast category.

The Podcasters are

  • Markus Völter (freelancer, associated with ITEMIS)
  • Stevan Tilkov (innoQ)
  • Christian Weyer (thinktecture)
  • Michael Stal (Siemens)

To stay in touch with reality we have split up the podcast in three subcategories:

  • General Architecture Topics (sponsored by IBM)
  • Java and Software Architecture (sponsored by innQ, itemis, thinktecture and Siemens)
  • Microsoft Technologies and Architecture (sponsored by Microsoft)

There are already 4 episodes available. Episode 0 is more intended to introduce ourselves. Episodes 1-3 cover patterns in general, as well as patterns in Java respectively .NET.

 

Listen, enjoy, and give us feedback